Key Points

  • Authenticity beats algorithmic optimization: While AI can replicate information, it cannot replicate genuine human perspective, community, and voice — making authentic content the most defensible strategy against AI competition.
  • Depth creates unshakeable competitive moats: Publishers thriving in the AI era go obsessively deep into specific topics and build genuine communities around shared obsessions, rather than covering subjects broadly for search optimization.
  • Community ownership drives sustainable revenue: The most successful publishers treat readers as participants rather than consumers, creating subscription models based on belonging and genuine connection rather than just content access.
  • Specificity trumps broad appeal: Publishers who choose to be "something specific to someone" rather than "everything to everyone" build more engaged audiences and generate higher-value traffic that advertisers actually want to reach.
  • Authentic engagement patterns generate better monetization: Community-driven sites with genuine user investment create longer sessions, higher return rates, and audience behavior that's significantly more valuable to both publishers and advertisers than hollow traffic.

While publishers scramble to optimize for search engines that increasingly don't send traffic, the smart money has figured out something crucial: AI can replicate information, but it can't replicate authenticity. And readers are getting hungry for the real thing.

Here's what nobody wants to admit: most online content feels manufactured because it is manufactured. Publishers have been optimizing for algorithms for so long, they've forgotten how to optimize for humans. But there's a rebellion brewing, and it's happening in the places where publishers decided to get weird, get deep, and get real.

The publishers thriving right now aren't the ones with the  best SEO strategies or the most sophisticated content management systems. They're the ones who figured out that authentic depth beats algorithmic optimization every single time. They're building something AI fundamentally can't replicate: genuine human perspective, community, and voice.

We're watching four different approaches to authenticity emerge, each one proving that depth and personality aren't just nice-to-haves, they're survival strategies.

New call-to-action

Read the full guide.

Tip 1: Build Quirky Community Around Shared Obsessions (The Novelry Model)

The Novelry gets something most publishers miss: people don't just want information, they want to belong somewhere. This UK-based writing community has turned literary education into a genuine cultural movement by embracing their weirdness instead of hiding it.

They don't just teach writing; they've created a universe around it. Their tone is part mentor, part cheerleader, part slightly unhinged writing coach who genuinely believes every student can write the next great novel. It's authentic because it's specific. You couldn't mistake their voice for anyone else's.

What publishers can steal from The Novelry:

Their community model turns consumers into participants. Students don't just take courses: they become part of a writing culture with its own language, rituals, and inside jokes. When someone graduates from a Novelry course, they're not just certified writers; they're members of a tribe.

The monetization is brilliant because it's authentic. They're not selling courses, they're selling transformation and community membership. People pay premium prices because they're not just buying education; they're buying belonging.

The depth strategy: Instead of covering writing broadly, they go obsessively deep into specific aspects of craft. Their courses aren't "Writing 101," they're "How to Write a Bestselling Thriller" or "Literary Fiction That Actually Sells." Specificity creates authority.

This approach works because it's defensible. AI can generate writing tips, but it can't replicate the specific culture and community that The Novelry has built around those tips. The information might be replicable; the experience isn't.

Tip 2: Go Deep Enough to Change Minds (The Atlantic Model)

The Atlantic figured out something crucial about the AI era: surface-level analysis is dead. If you're not going deep enough to change how readers think about a topic, you're just providing raw material for AI to synthesize.

Their approach to depth isn't just about word count, it's about intellectual rigor. They don't just report what happened; they explain why it matters, what it means, and how it connects to larger patterns. Their pieces often challenge conventional wisdom because that's where real value lives.

What publishers can steal from The Atlantic:

Their writers aren't just subject matter experts, they're intellectual provocateurs. They take positions that make you think, even if you disagree. That's the kind of content that generates discussion, shares, and loyalty.

The subscription model works because their analysis isn't available anywhere else. When major news breaks, dozens of outlets will report the facts. The Atlantic will publish the piece that explains what those facts actually mean for democracy, technology, or culture.

The authenticity strategy: Their writers have genuine expertise and aren't afraid to show intellectual vulnerability. They'll admit when they're wrong, change positions based on new evidence, and explore complex topics without reducing them to simple answers.

Playwire's audience intelligence solutions recognize this kind of engagement. Deep, thoughtful content creates the kind of user behavior that's valuable to both advertisers and publishers: longer session times, higher return rates, and audiences that actually read rather than just skim.

New call-to-action

Tip 3: Embrace Experimental Weirdness as Brand Identity (McSweeney's Model)

McSweeney's cracked the code on something most publishers are too scared to try: being genuinely weird in a way that attracts rather than repels readers. Dave Eggers built a literary empire by refusing to conform to industry expectations about what publishing should look like.

Their quarterly magazine has arrived as junk mail, giant playing cards, and a box with a painted head on it. Their Internet Tendency publishes humor pieces with titles like "I'm Comic Sans, Asshole" that get millions of views. It's not weird for weird's sake, it's weird with purpose.

What publishers can steal from McSweeney's:

Authenticity can be a design strategy, not just a content strategy. Every aspect of their operation reflects their values: experimental, literary, slightly subversive, and deeply committed to the craft of writing.

Their community model works because it's inclusive of misfits. Their stated mission is to champion "ambitious and inspired new writing" and "challenge conventional expectations." That attracts writers and readers who don't fit elsewhere.

The depth approach: They publish established voices like Stephen King and Joyce Carol Oates alongside complete unknowns. Quality matters more than credentials. Their editorial judgment has become their brand, readers trust that anything McSweeney's publishes will be worth their time.

The nonprofit model gives them freedom to experiment without quarterly profit pressures. They can take risks that traditional publishers can't, which creates loyalty among readers who want to support genuine literary culture.

Tip 4: Own Your Community Completely (Defector Model)

Defector cracked the code on something most publishers still don't understand: when you own the community, you own the future. This worker-owned sports and culture site proved that authenticity plus community ownership creates something unshakeable.

They didn't just leave their previous publication, they took their audience with them. That's only possible when the connection is genuine and personal, not just transactional.

New call-to-action

Visit our full resource center on generative AI.

What publishers can steal from Defector:

Their subscription model works because subscribers aren't just buying content, they're supporting a community they genuinely care about. The $79-$119 annual subscriptions include commenting privileges, exclusive content, and genuine interaction with writers.

The worker-owned structure creates authentic investment. Writers aren't just employees grinding out content, they're owners building something together. That energy is palpable in their work.

The community strategy: They don't just cover sports — they've created a cultural space where sports intersect with politics, labor, social justice, and humor. Their readers come for the community as much as the coverage.

Playwire's RAMP platform understands this dynamic. Community-driven sites generate different engagement patterns than traditional content sites: longer sessions, more return visits, and audiences that actively participate rather than passively consume.

Build Your Authentic Moat Before AI Gets Smarter

The window for authenticity isn't closing, it's just getting more valuable. As AI gets better at generating generic content, genuine human perspective becomes the scarce resource. Publishers who figure out their authentic voice and build genuine communities around it will own the most defensible positions in digital media.

The common thread across all four approaches? They stopped trying to be everything to everyone and started being something specific to someone. They chose depth over breadth, community over reach, and authenticity over optimization.

Contact Playwire today and discover how our platform amplifies revenue from authentic publisher brands.

Updated Apply Now